Dan just put up a bunch of previews of RB3 from E3. Check out the giant list or see below:
Awards and Nominations
1Up
Best Music Game 1UP's Best Games of E3 2010
Alternative Press
Top 10 Games of E3 10 Must Have Games From E3
Game Pro
Best of E3 Best of E3
Gamer Headquarters
Best Music Game of E3 Best of E3 2010
IGN
Best Music/Rhythm Game Best of E3
PC World
Thing that made me a fan of a series when I wasn't before: Rock Band 3's Real Guitars Fear and Loathing at E3: Awards and Accolades
Use My Things
Most Interesting E3 Awards
Articles
1Up E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Pro Instruments Demo
1Up Rock Band 3 (PS3)
4 Player Podcast E3 2010: The David Awards
Aeropause E3 Preview: Rock Band 3 (Multi)
AggroGamer E3 2010 Hands-On: Rock Band 3
Ars Technica Hands on: Rock Band 3 instruments reward real skill
Atomic Gamer E3 2010 Preview: Rock Band 3
Attack of the Fanboy News: MadCatz E3 2010 – Rock Band 3 gear, F.L.Y. 9 PS3 Wireless Flight Stick, Xbox 360 Wheel, more
Awesome Game Blog E3 2010: Rock Band 3
Battle Strats E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Preview
Big Picture Big Sound E3 2010: 10 Best Games From the Electronic Entertainment Expo
Big picture sound E3 2010: 10 Best Games From the Electronic Entertainment Expo
Bit Mob Rock Band 3: A Skeptic's Take
Blip TV E3 2010 Harmonix Rockband 3 Conference
Coin-OP Tv E3 2010 Expo reactions (Tues-Thurs)
Coin-OP Tv E3 Expo 2010
Consequence of Sound Watch: Rock Band 3 (CoS Exclusive)
Coolest Gadgets What else to expect from RockBand 3
CoS Watch: Rock Band 3 (CoS Exclusive)
Crave Rock Band 3 - E3 2010 Trailer
Crazy Gamer News E3 2010: Rock Band 3 demo impressions (Gamer Tell)
Critical Gamer E3: Rock Band 3 Preview
CtrlAltKill Preview: Rock Band 3 to score you chicks and gigs?
Destructoid E3 10: Rock Band 3 on DS detailed
Device Magazine Rock Band 3 Review at E3
Dmonkey Studios E3 2010 rockband 3 Conference
El Comercio El juego 'Rock Band 3' que enseña a tocar música saldrá en noviembre
El Comercio E3 2010 - Impresiones de Rock Band 3
Engadget Rock Band 3 Fender Mustang Pro guitar controller and MIDI-Pro adapter eyes-on
Engadget Rock Band 3 keyboard hands-on (video)
Eurogamer E3: Rock Band 3
Examiner Rock Band 3' pre-E3 details
Examiner The Doors featured on Rock Band 3
Fox AL Harmonix riffs on Rock Band 3 features
Fox News E3 2010: Ten Favorite Games
Fragland E3 Hands-on: Rock Band 3 (All platforms)
Future Looks E3 2010 – Harmonix Unleashes Rockband 3 and Dance Central and Leonard Nimoy is a Gamer?
G4TV Hands-On Rock Band 3 from E3 2010 Live!
G4TV E3 2010: Our First Look At Rock Band 3
G4TV E3 2010: MTV Games Booth
Game Boyz E3 Thoughts by Kirby Y - E3 is now over and there is still more work to do
Game Informer Rock Band 3 Hands On At E3
Game Informer Rock Band 3 Now With Real Guitars
Game Journos E3 2010: My Final Thoughts
Game Kicker SideQuesting E3 2010 Impressions: Rock Band 3 (Side Questing)
Game Kult E3> Zoom : Rock Band 3
Game Pro E3 2010: Rock Band 3 – Hands on with all the new instruments
Game Pro E3 2010: New Rock Band 3 Pro Controllers
Game Rant Hands On: Rock Band 3
Game Revolution Rock Band 3 - Xbox360
Game Spot Rock Band 3 Hands-On
Game Spot E3 2010 Stage Demo: Rock Band 3
Game Trailers E3 2010: In With The New Interview
Game Trailers E3 2010: Debut Trailer HD
Game Xplain E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Pro Six String Guitar Controller
Gamer Limit E3′10: Hands on with Rock Band 3’s keyboard – A long road to Chopin
Gamer Limit E3’10: Rock Band 3 hands-on impressions – the first true band “simulator”
Gamer Tell E3 2010: Rock Band 3 demo impressions
GameRant Hands On: Rock Band 3
Gamers Hell Rock Band 3 Announced and E3 2010 Trailers/Screens
Gaming Union E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Hands-On Impressions
Gaming Excellence E3 2010: Harmonix, MTV Games Reinvent Music Games With Rock Band 3
Gaming Ring E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Interview
Gaming Ring E3 2010: Rockband 3 Hands On Preview
Gaming Shogun Rock Band 3 Impressions from the 2010 Electronic Entertainment Expo
Giant Bomb E3 Quick Impressions: Dance Central
Giant Bomb Giant Bomb at E3 2010: Day 02
Girl Gamer E3 First Look: Rock Band 3 In-House Demo
Gizmodo How Harmonix Is Tricking Lazy Gamers Into Learning Real Instruments
Gizmodo Hands On With Rock Band 3's Pro Guitar and Keyboard (Keytar!)
Gizmodo Rock Band 3 Will Try to Teach You How to Actually Play Instruments
Gizmos for Geeks Rock Band 3 to Feature Keyboards
Globo Com instrumentos reais, 'Rock band 3' quer ensinar a tocar música
Go Nintendo Rock Band 3 DS Impressions (Piklbit)
Grab Geek Points Rock Band 3 2010 Preview
Grab Geek Points Rock Band 3 E3 2010 Preview
Home Theater Forum OFFICIAL HTF COVERAGE OF E3 2010
How Stuff Works TechStuff Rocks Out With Rock Band 3
i4u E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Details and Trailer unveiled
ICrontic Rock Band 3 demonstration at E3 2010
IGN E3 2010: Melting Faces in Rock Band 3 DS
IGN E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Preview
IGN E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Real Guitar Impressions
IGN Rock Band 3 Confirmed for AU and NZ
Inland SoCal Video-Hands on
Inland SoCal Rock Band 3 adds real instruments
Inland SoCal Vote for your Rock Band 3 demo
Joystiq Have a look at the Rock Band 3 keyboard & MIDI PRO-Adapter
Joystiq Preview: Rock Band 3 Pro mode
Kombo E3 2010: Rock Band 3's Keyboard Hands-On
Kombo E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Hands-On
Kombo E3 2010: We've Seen the New Rock Band 3 Pro Guitars, and They are Mighty
Kombo E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Instruments by Mad Catz Hands-on
Kotaku Man Vs. Massive Rock Band Set List
LA Times E3 2010: MTV outsources Rock Band instruments, embraces dancing
Legit Reviews MTV & Harmonix Demos Rock Band 3 at E3 2010
Level UP Video 1
Level UP Rock Band 3: la estrella del E310
Level UP Video 2
Level UP Video 3
Mashable Rock Band 3 Live Demo at E3
Metal Insider Rock Band 3 Might Actually Teach You Music
MMOMFG Rock Band 3 – Hands-on Impressions from E3 2010
Monsters and Critics E3 2010: Hands-On With 'Rock Band 3'
Multiplayer.it Rock Band 3 - Una rivoluzione?
Multiplayer.it Rock Band 3 - Videoanteprima E3 2010
N4G E3 10; Rock Band 3 - The PS3 Attitude Preview (PS2 Attitude)
Nerdy Show E3 Vidcasts :: Rockin’ With Harmonix
New Game Network ROCK BAND 3 PREVIEW - E310
Newsarama ROCKBAND 3 @ E3 2010
Nukezilla E3 10: Dance Central and Rock Band 3 Impressions (With Pictures!)
Nukezilla E3 10: Rock Band 3 Playable With Your Own Instruments
Original Sound Version E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Is The Real Thing
Paste Magazine Paste Goes to E3: Day 3
PiklBit Rock Band 3
Plastic Axe Hands-On With Pro Guitar in Rock Band 3
PNOsker Rock Band 3 Impressions
Pocket Lint Rock Band 3 demoed at E3
Prefix Magazine Rock Band 3 Drops Nuke On Game Wars, Introduces Keytar
Press Democrat E3 Wednesday: 2,144 words about 14 games
Press Fire Fuck You!
PS3 Attitude E3 10; Rock Band 3 – The PS3 Attitude Preview
PS3-Sense E3 2010: PS3-Sense video item: dag 4 in Los Angeles
PSN Nation Special Episode-E3 2010 Day Three
Punch Jump E3: Rock Band 3 PS3, Xbox 360, Wii keyboard play rocks
Real Poor E3 10; Rock Band 3 - The PS3 Attitude Preview (N4G)
Road 4 Blog E3’10: Rock Band 3 hands-on impressions – the first true band “simulator” (Gamer Tell)
Rock Band Aide Rock Band 3 DS Hands-On… Oh, and Yes is in Rock Band 3!
Rock Band Aide Possible Rock Band 3 Release Confirmation and UK Peripheral Pricing
Rock Band Aide Rock Band 3 Lead Designer Dan Teasdale Answers Your Questions
Rock Band Aide 15 Things We’ve Learned at E3 about Rock Band 3
Rolling Stone Brazil Quase de verdade
Sarcastic Gamer SG E3 2010: Rock Band 3 has me at hello
Scatter Tech Rock Band 3 at E3
SDDT E3 2010: 'Rock Band 3'
Seriously! E3 2010: Rock Band 3
SF Gate E3 a peek at what's to come: 3-D, downloads
ShoGunGamer Rock Band 3 First Look [E3 2010]
Side Questing E3 2010 Impressions: Rock Band 3
SmashPad E3 2010 Showfloor Preview: Rock Band 3
Spike E3 2010: Rock Band 3 - Debut Trailer
SpillVerket En revolusjon for musikkspillene?
Student Voice Things get real with Rock Band 3
Sugar Gamers E3 Special: Showed up for the Gig, Partied with the Rockband (By Rebecca “Bonks” Rothschild)
Sydney Morning Herald Split Screen: The future of music games
Tech News Daily Rock Band 3 Debuts Even More Life-Like Guitars
Technologizer Music Games Get Real With Fully-Functioning Guitars
The Buzz Media E3 Rock Band 3 Preview
The Gamers Garage Gamers Garage: Episode 143 – E3 2010 Day Two
The Koalition Rockband 3 Will Shape The Future
The Review Crew Hands On Rock Band 3: The New Instruments
The Tanooki Rock Band 3 demo impressions
Trendific Kinect: Dance Central Pre E3 2010 Media Briefing
Tweakers.net E3: Rock Band 3
VG Revolution E3 2010: Rock Band 3 Hands On Impressions
VG247 Harmonix details Rock band 3’s guitar controller
VGChartz E3 Preview: Rock Band 3
WCBS 880 Dishin' Digital
Wii Nintendo.net (E3 2010) Rock Band 3 (DS) – Hands-On First Impressions
Winnipegfree Press Video
WireJacked Rock Band 3 instruments, screens, and info revealed
Worth Playing PS3/X360 Preview - 'Rock Band 3'
Xbox 360 Digest X3D @ E3 2010: Harmonix/MTV Games booth
YNN E3: Rock Band 3
Youtube Rock Band 3 Hands On Demo (G4TV)
Youtube E3 2010 -- COE @ MTV/Harmonix (Rock Band 3 P3)
Youtube E3 2010 -- COE @ MTV/Harmonix (Rock Band 3 P2)
Youtube E3 2010 -- COE @ MTV/Harmonix (Rock Band 3 P1)
Youtube Rock Band 3 E3 2010
Youtube Private Rock Band 3 Demo at E32010
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
Sunday, June 20, 2010
...E3 2010 Pics
Check out our booth before everyone got there:
I managed to get a ton of pics next to the Pro Guitar display:
The Dance Central Area has a really cool setup:
We had 3 Rock Band 3 stages - this was the smallest:
Bryn and I had 1 break the entire time, during which we took this shot:
We spent most of our time in one of the private rooms giving demos and letting people play the Pro Guitars:
Holy crap there was a lot of stuff to tear down:
And at the end there was a party on the roof of the Standard where we stayed. My coworkers jumped in the pool and caused mayhem. I pretty much just went to bed as I was sick all week!
I managed to get a ton of pics next to the Pro Guitar display:
The Dance Central girls were loving the Beatles setup. Well one of them looked unhappy until I turned on no-fail:
We had 3 Rock Band 3 stages - this was the smallest:
Bryn and I had 1 break the entire time, during which we took this shot:
We spent most of our time in one of the private rooms giving demos and letting people play the Pro Guitars:
Holy crap there was a lot of stuff to tear down:
And at the end there was a party on the roof of the Standard where we stayed. My coworkers jumped in the pool and caused mayhem. I pretty much just went to bed as I was sick all week!
Sunday, June 13, 2010
Thursday, June 10, 2010
...Rock Band 3 in USA Today
They have a long video in which I'm interviewed here about Rock Band Pro:
More articles:
http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gamehunters/post/2010/06/rock-band-3-the-songs-announced-so-far-/1
http://kotaku.com/5559801/rock-band-3-teaches-you-to-rock-with-real-guitars--keyboards?skyline=true&s=i
http://www.joystiq.com/2010/06/10/rock-band-3-keyboard-revealed-by-usa-today/
http://www.engadget.com/2010/06/10/rock-band-3-keyboard-revealed-looks-like-a-keyboard/
More articles:
http://content.usatoday.com/communities/gamehunters/post/2010/06/rock-band-3-the-songs-announced-so-far-/1
http://kotaku.com/5559801/rock-band-3-teaches-you-to-rock-with-real-guitars--keyboards?skyline=true&s=i
http://www.joystiq.com/2010/06/10/rock-band-3-keyboard-revealed-by-usa-today/
http://www.engadget.com/2010/06/10/rock-band-3-keyboard-revealed-looks-like-a-keyboard/
Saturday, June 05, 2010
Saturday, May 15, 2010
...the feel of Halo 3 versus Modern Warfare
So I've been playing the Halo: Reach beta lately. While playing I was reminded me of a conversation I had with a Bungie employee a few months after the release of Modern Warfare.
He asked me what I thought of MW and after a few minutes of discussion I said something like "I feel like I am good when I play Modern Warfare but when I play Halo I often feel like I suck." He asked why I thought that was and I at the time I didn't have a good answer. Playing Halo: Reach reminded me of this and got me thinking about this again. Sorry that this isn't exactly topical but I seem to never let a question go until I have some kind of answer for it :)
Here are some facets to the games that made MW more of a general positive multiplayer experience to low-level player like me than Halo 3:
The Time it takes to kill enemies
Relative to MW, players in Halo 3 multiplayer can take a lot of damage from weapons before they die. I am told high-level players really enjoy this aspect as it leads to prolonged encounters. For low-level players however it often feels like good planning and positioning matter much less than your ability to keep your reticule on an opponent. I often come up with a good plan that allows me to flank my opponents rear, only to have them turn around and blow me away. This even happens when I join another teammate who is currently engaged with a high-level player.
Weapon and equipment acquisition
In MW, players choose the weapons and abilities they are going to use before they start the map. MW players can also change this loadout whenever they die. Players know what they are going to use while in the level and can change their strategy as they choose. It is easy to experiment with different weapons and abilities until you find a combination that works for your style.
In Halo 3, weapons are spawned at designer-specified locations on the map at specific intervals. This style of gameplay skews kills towards players with good map knowledge and familiarity of weapon behaviors. Learning the ins-and-outs of each map and weapon takes time investment and isn't necessarily transferable between maps.
The player leveling system
Halo 3 has a player skill system that is based on Trueskill. As you play games and win or lose, your ranking number can increase or decrease depending on the rank of who you are playing and how you do. There is also playlist specific experience values denoted visually by icons. The iconography, while a little vague, never goes down in rank.
MW has an experience number for players that only goes up. The better you do in a session, the faster it grows towards the next number. Each level brings with it new abilities or weapons that the player can choose to use. Underneath the hood, MW does have a system for smart matchmaking (Trueskill?) but this number is not outward facing. As a low-level player, I find this system of only positive rewards much more fulfilling.
Thursday, May 13, 2010
Thursday, May 06, 2010
Friday, April 02, 2010
...First Karaoke of the year pics
A bunch of us got a room at Do Re Mi for some serious singing.
Guess the song!
BChan's first ever karaoke song.
All together now!
Fin.
Guess the song!
BChan's first ever karaoke song.
All together now!
Fin.
...Pax East
Tuesday, March 09, 2010
Sunday, February 28, 2010
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
Sunday, February 07, 2010
...Late 2009 Pics
Mom's brisket - if you don't like brisket, you haven't tried this.
Christmas party pics.
Birthday cake and dinner. Yummy lobster.
The Jesus Lizard!
Best Arcade left in America? Funspot - the place where records are broken....
I finally got a comfy couch. But it's leather and huge! Problem solved - got a cover and rearranged the living room. Combine that with my new home theater and my place is a good place to relax again.
Recently got back from a work trip. Check out this crazy-nice hotel room...
Sara had a birthday party too...
Monday, February 01, 2010
...My Best Movies of 2009
Top 5:
1. The Hurt Locker
2. Anvil
3. Food Inc.
4. Avatar (3d)
5. Up
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Star Trek
Where the Wild Things Are
Zombieland
Moon
Gomorra
All my 2009 reviews are here.
1. The Hurt Locker
2. Anvil
3. Food Inc.
4. Avatar (3d)
5. Up
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Star Trek
Where the Wild Things Are
Zombieland
Moon
Gomorra
All my 2009 reviews are here.
Friday, January 29, 2010
...My Best Books of 2009
Actually strike that...these are the top books I read in 2009. I barely read anything that came out in this year :)
Top 5:
The Road
Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health
Body by Science: A Research Based Program to Get the Results You Want in 12 Minutes a Week
The Primal Blueprint: Reprogram Your Genes for Effortless Weight Loss, Vibrant Health, and Boundless Energy
Understanding Comics
Honorable Mention:
The Wisdom of Crowds
Anticancer: A New Way of Life
The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals
What Shamu Taught Me About Life, Love, and Marriage: Lessons for People from Animals and Their Trainers
Power of 10: The Once-A-Week Slow Motion Fitness Revolution
All my 2009 reviews are here.
Top 5:
The Road
Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health
Body by Science: A Research Based Program to Get the Results You Want in 12 Minutes a Week
The Primal Blueprint: Reprogram Your Genes for Effortless Weight Loss, Vibrant Health, and Boundless Energy
Understanding Comics
Honorable Mention:
The Wisdom of Crowds
Anticancer: A New Way of Life
The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals
What Shamu Taught Me About Life, Love, and Marriage: Lessons for People from Animals and Their Trainers
Power of 10: The Once-A-Week Slow Motion Fitness Revolution
All my 2009 reviews are here.
Monday, January 25, 2010
...My Best Music of 2009
Top 5:
1. Coalesce - Ox (not the EP)
2. Converge - Axe to Fall
3. Ladyfinger(ne) - Dusk
4. Kylesa - Static Tensions
5. The Horrors - Primary Colours
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Megasus - Megasus
The Beatles - The Beatles in Mono (Box Set)
Nirvana - Bleach (Remastered)
Baroness - Blue Record
Lightning Bolt - Early Delights
Nirvana - Live at Reading
The Jesus Lizard - Head (Remastered)
Yob - The Great Cessation
Zu - Carboniferous
Gallows - Grey Britain
Trash Talk - Trash Talk
Rumplestiltskin Grinder - Living for Death, Destroying the Rest
The Bronx - The Bronx 3
All my 2009 reviews are here.
1. Coalesce - Ox (not the EP)
2. Converge - Axe to Fall
3. Ladyfinger(ne) - Dusk
4. Kylesa - Static Tensions
5. The Horrors - Primary Colours
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Megasus - Megasus
The Beatles - The Beatles in Mono (Box Set)
Nirvana - Bleach (Remastered)
Baroness - Blue Record
Lightning Bolt - Early Delights
Nirvana - Live at Reading
The Jesus Lizard - Head (Remastered)
Yob - The Great Cessation
Zu - Carboniferous
Gallows - Grey Britain
Trash Talk - Trash Talk
Rumplestiltskin Grinder - Living for Death, Destroying the Rest
The Bronx - The Bronx 3
All my 2009 reviews are here.
Thursday, January 14, 2010
...My Best Games of 2009
Top 5:
1. Batman Arkham Asylum
2. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
3. Uncharted 2
4. UFC Undisputed
5. 'Splosion Man
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Pixeljunk Shooter
Assasins Creed 2
Trials HD
Fifa 10
Peggle (Iphone)
Shadow Complex
Resident Evil 5
Death Tank
I'm not including 2 games I worked on that I think were great, The Beatles: Rock Band and Rock Band Unplugged :)
All my 2009 reviews are here.
1. Batman Arkham Asylum
2. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
3. Uncharted 2
4. UFC Undisputed
5. 'Splosion Man
Honorable Mention (in no particular order):
Pixeljunk Shooter
Assasins Creed 2
Trials HD
Fifa 10
Peggle (Iphone)
Shadow Complex
Resident Evil 5
Death Tank
I'm not including 2 games I worked on that I think were great, The Beatles: Rock Band and Rock Band Unplugged :)
All my 2009 reviews are here.
Sunday, January 10, 2010
...All Reviews for 2009
Here are all the books, games, and music I got in 2009. I'll post my best of lists in a few days.
Recommended items in Bold.
Music:
Mew - And the Glass Handed Kites
Baroness - Blue Record
Arcade Fire - Funeral
Girl Talk - Night Ripper
Coalesce - Ox (EP)
Slayer - World Painted Blood
Jemina Pearl - Break It Up
Working For a Nuclear Free City - Businessmen & Ghosts
The Modern Lovers - The Modern Lovers
Lightning Bolt - Early Delights
Tides - Giant
Them Crooked Vultures - Them Crooked Vultures
AC/DC - Backtracks
Hall & Oats - The Essential Darryl Hall & John Oats
Converge - Axe to Fall
Nirvana - Bleach (Remastered)
LCD Soundsystem - LCD Soundsystem
Danzig - Danzig
Nirvana - Live at Reading
The Jesus Lizard - Head (Remastered)
LCD Soundsystem - 45:33
The Beatles The Beatles in Mono (Box Set)
LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
Legacy - Beyond Hurt Beyond Hell
Public Image Ltd. - The Flowers of Romance
Pissed Jeans - King of Jeans
Future of the Left - Travels With Myself and Another
Yob - The Great Cessation
Zu - Carboniferous
Coalesce - Give Them Rope She Said V2.0
Michael Jackson - Off the Wall (Special Edition)
Coalesce - Ox
Sonic Youth - The Eternal
Tweak Bird - Reservations
The Horrors - Primary Colours
Isis - Wavering Radiant
Fever Ray - Fever Ray
Gallows - Grey Britain
Japandroids - Post-Nothing
Graf Orlock - Destination Time Today
Trash Talk - Trash Talk
Death - ...For the Whole World to See
Ladyfinger(ne) - Dusk
Kylesa - Static Tensions
Mastodon - Crack the Skye
Tears for Fears - Songs From the Big Chair
Rumplestiltskin Grinder - Living for Death, Destroying the Rest
Megasus - Megasus
Portishead - Third
The Lonely Island - Incredibad
The Swell - Tonnage
Sleep - Sleep's Holy Mountain
The Bronx - The Bronx 3
Movies:
An Education
Avatar (3d)
The Road
Where the Wild Things Are
A Serious Man
Capitalism: A Love Story
Zombieland
It Might Get Loud
District 9
Inglorious Basterds
Humpday
Moon
The Hurt Locker
Food Inc.
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Public Enemies
Tokyo
Up
Tyson
The Hangover
Drag Me to Hell
Star Trek
Anvil
Crank High Voltage
I Love you Man
Watchmen
Gomorra
The Wrestler
Books:
The Wisdom of Crowds
David Cross - I Drink For a Reason
Anticancer: A New Way of Life
Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain
The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals
The Cartoon Guide to Physics
World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War
What Shamu Taught Me About Life, Love, and Marriage: Lessons for People from Animals and Their Trainers
The Primal Blueprint: Reprogram Your Genes for Effortless Weight Loss, Vibrant Health, and Boundless Energy
Power of 10: The Once-A-Week Slow Motion Fitness Revolution
Game Feel
Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid
Body by Science: A Research Based Program to Get the Results You Want in 12 Minutes a Week
The Hero with a Thousand Faces
Story: Substance, Structure, Style and The Principles of Screenwriting
The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008
Fretboard Logic
How to Win Friends & Influence People
Understanding Comics
The Road
Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health
Hip: The History
Games:
Pixeljunk Shooter
Assasins Creed 2
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Fifa Soccer 10
Uncharted 2
Demon's Souls
Madden 10
Halo ODST
Batman Arkham Asylum
Trials HD
Peggle (Iphone)
Shadow Complex
'Splosion Man
Battlefield 1943
Ghostbusters
UFC Undisputed
Fallout 3
Resident Evil 5
Death Tank
Recommended items in Bold.
Music:
Mew - And the Glass Handed Kites
Baroness - Blue Record
Arcade Fire - Funeral
Girl Talk - Night Ripper
Coalesce - Ox (EP)
Slayer - World Painted Blood
Jemina Pearl - Break It Up
Working For a Nuclear Free City - Businessmen & Ghosts
The Modern Lovers - The Modern Lovers
Lightning Bolt - Early Delights
Tides - Giant
Them Crooked Vultures - Them Crooked Vultures
AC/DC - Backtracks
Hall & Oats - The Essential Darryl Hall & John Oats
Converge - Axe to Fall
Nirvana - Bleach (Remastered)
LCD Soundsystem - LCD Soundsystem
Danzig - Danzig
Nirvana - Live at Reading
The Jesus Lizard - Head (Remastered)
LCD Soundsystem - 45:33
The Beatles The Beatles in Mono (Box Set)
LCD Soundsystem - Sound of Silver
Legacy - Beyond Hurt Beyond Hell
Public Image Ltd. - The Flowers of Romance
Pissed Jeans - King of Jeans
Future of the Left - Travels With Myself and Another
Yob - The Great Cessation
Zu - Carboniferous
Coalesce - Give Them Rope She Said V2.0
Michael Jackson - Off the Wall (Special Edition)
Coalesce - Ox
Sonic Youth - The Eternal
Tweak Bird - Reservations
The Horrors - Primary Colours
Isis - Wavering Radiant
Fever Ray - Fever Ray
Gallows - Grey Britain
Japandroids - Post-Nothing
Graf Orlock - Destination Time Today
Trash Talk - Trash Talk
Death - ...For the Whole World to See
Ladyfinger(ne) - Dusk
Kylesa - Static Tensions
Mastodon - Crack the Skye
Tears for Fears - Songs From the Big Chair
Rumplestiltskin Grinder - Living for Death, Destroying the Rest
Megasus - Megasus
Portishead - Third
The Lonely Island - Incredibad
The Swell - Tonnage
Sleep - Sleep's Holy Mountain
The Bronx - The Bronx 3
Movies:
An Education
Avatar (3d)
The Road
Where the Wild Things Are
A Serious Man
Capitalism: A Love Story
Zombieland
It Might Get Loud
District 9
Inglorious Basterds
Humpday
Moon
The Hurt Locker
Food Inc.
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Public Enemies
Tokyo
Up
Tyson
The Hangover
Drag Me to Hell
Star Trek
Anvil
Crank High Voltage
I Love you Man
Watchmen
Gomorra
The Wrestler
Books:
The Wisdom of Crowds
David Cross - I Drink For a Reason
Anticancer: A New Way of Life
Musicophilia: Tales of Music and the Brain
The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals
The Cartoon Guide to Physics
World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War
What Shamu Taught Me About Life, Love, and Marriage: Lessons for People from Animals and Their Trainers
The Primal Blueprint: Reprogram Your Genes for Effortless Weight Loss, Vibrant Health, and Boundless Energy
Power of 10: The Once-A-Week Slow Motion Fitness Revolution
Game Feel
Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid
Body by Science: A Research Based Program to Get the Results You Want in 12 Minutes a Week
The Hero with a Thousand Faces
Story: Substance, Structure, Style and The Principles of Screenwriting
The Return of Depression Economics and the Crisis of 2008
Fretboard Logic
How to Win Friends & Influence People
Understanding Comics
The Road
Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health
Hip: The History
Games:
Pixeljunk Shooter
Assasins Creed 2
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
Fifa Soccer 10
Uncharted 2
Demon's Souls
Madden 10
Halo ODST
Batman Arkham Asylum
Trials HD
Peggle (Iphone)
Shadow Complex
'Splosion Man
Battlefield 1943
Ghostbusters
UFC Undisputed
Fallout 3
Resident Evil 5
Death Tank
Monday, January 04, 2010
...Bioshock AI Q&A with Dean Tate
Dean Tate is a Senior Designer at Harmonix. Immediately previous to his time here at Harmonix Dean worked on Bioshock and Bioshock 2 - specifically working on AI and level design. Seeing an opportunity, I decided to have a Q&A with Dean. The questions here primarily focus on Bioshock's AI and their integration Bioshock's levels - I think this aspect was particularly well done in Bioshock. I hope you enjoy peeling back the curtain a bit to see how it was done and what was learned.
Sylvain: How much of the AI in Bioshock is scripted versus autonomous?
Dean: A great deal of our AI was scripted but we worked really hard to somewhat mask that fact. In a lot of games, it can be really obvious when an AI is scripted versus when an AI is systemic. This is something we really wanted to avoid. In a lot of cases, this just meant exercising some restraint; one thing that can make scripted AIs appear to very obviously be scripted is when they display some whacky behaviour that you never see the systemic AIs use. So for example, Splicer AIs in Bioshock take cover, but they don't use cover animations. So we avoided having situations where the player would enter a room and AIs would be scripted to be laying in wait behind cover and then pop out and attack. We wanted consistent behavior between our systemic and scripted AIs.
We also worked really hard to blur the line between 'scripted' and 'systemic'; our AI scripting system, with enough designer crafting and tweaking, could very gracefully handle having an AI that is scripted become systemic without players noticing the transition. It also allowed players to intervene and affect when that transition occurs. Dealing damage to an AI for example to stop it from continuing down it's scripted path. I think everyone on the level scripting teams took great strides to use this ability to great effect and avoid crafting situations that were very obviously scripted. Scenes that occur behind bullet-proof glass, for example.
Sylvain: What kind of high-level (and low level) systems were used for AI thinking? How did you interact with the system (did you manipulate data or edit script logic or just go into code)?
Dean: I didn't touch the low-level code at all, which was all handled by our AI Programming Lead, John Abercrombie. A lot of our AI system was hard coded; things like how our ecology functioned and how AIs viewed each other, AI abilities and weapons functionality and behaviour, etc. Getting those things right was just a process of heavy collaboration and back and forth iteration. At a level above that, I had access to and could tweak all of the numbers that affected discrete AI behaviors. Things like AI movement parameters, attack parameters (how often an AI attacks, how far from the player it tries to remain, under which conditions it will initiate different attack and movement behaviors or weapons, etc). I did all of this by manipulating data in text files. Very high tech stuff (snort). Experimenting with changes to an AIs behaviors was quite a laborious affair that involved (if I remember right):
-Opening the correct text file
-Finding where I wanted to make a change to the text file data, and then saving the file
-Closing the file
-Running our level editor, and opening up one of my AI testing levels
-Tweaking a set of scripts so that they're spawn the correct AI (the one I had changed) when the level ran
-Baking the level content and data changes to a testkit
-Testing my changes to see if the desired effect had been attained, often while making sure a bunch of debug info was being displayed so I could be sure I was seeing the effects of my changes.
-Rinse, repeat
Each of these steps was important. For example, if I made a change to a parameter in the text file and then forgot to save and then close the text file before testing the change, the change would not take effect (I remember this because I made this mistake all the time!).
Things could and would often go wrong, and I'd need to repeat the entire process. I also sometimes ran into what I called "Placebo Parameters": parameters that were supposed to effect AI behaviors, but that in fact hadn't been hooked up yet in code (or, more often, weren't working because of a newly introduced bug). I'd tweak the value over and over again, checking the effect it had on the AI's behavior, stroking my chin and thinking "that didn't seem to make a difference...", tweaking the value some more, working towards getting the desired effect, before finally realizing "Hey! This isn't actually doing anything!" The lesson learned was that when a programmer gives you a new value to tweak, you should first set it to a minimum or maximum value and test it out; then, you can be sure it is doing what it is supposed to do.
And then, at a level above my base behavior editing and tweaking, level designers had some control over AIs through the use of our scripting system. The ability to initiate or cancel specific behaviors, toggle behaviors on and off, give AIs movement and navigation orders, etc.
Sylvain: Wow that's quite a long process for each change! How did you deal with changing an AI's behavior and making sure that it didn't mess up how they worked in all the other areas of the game?
Dean: It was quite a laborious process. When you're making incremental changes to any system, you want to make one change at a time, test it, make another small adjustment, test it again...making large sets of changes all at once makes it much harder to catalogue the effects of each individual change.
Making sure that changes didn't have unexpected knock-on affects was tough. Whenever large sets of changes were made I needed to make sure that our QA and Design teams were well aware of the changes and kept an eye out for abberent behaviors. Designers would focus on making sure any scripted sequences they had already implemented didn't become broken (thankfully, this didn't happen often) and QA would make sure that interactions between our AIs and other game systems (weapons, plasmids, etc) didn't become broken.
Sylvain: What kind of perceptual model did the AI use? What were the main parameters you had control of?
Dean: Wow, I'm remembering some pretty old stuff here. It's been years since the game was released, so I hope this is all accurate. To the best of my knowledge, it is.
The most interesting fact about our perceptual model is that Big Daddies are essentially deaf and blind. They have very little need for any sort of perceptual model up until the point that they have a target to attack. If that target is the player, than they will employ vision if they lose sight of the player; however, their vision is essentially 360 degrees and very long range, so basically if they lose the player they'll try to get within line of sight and then continue to attack. So if you think it's hard to lose a Big Daddy once it has started attacking, now you know you're not just imagining it.
Sylvain: I'm assuming then that they has a simple timeout after which they stop looking for you?
Dean: That's right. If I remember correctly, once a Big Daddy has chosen a target to attack, it won't return to a neutral state until the target is dead (this includes the player). Splicers are different. They will pursue a target they have lost sight of, and eventually lose interest and return to a neutral state. This happens after a timeout period that kicks in once the AI has lost sight of the target and then traveled to the target's last known location (AIs hold absolute knowledge of a target's location for a few seconds after they lose sight of it)
Our splicers used a perceptual model that is extremely similar in design to that used in other Irrational and Looking Glass games such as System Shock 2 and Thief, only tuned differently. Splicers are much more aware in general than their counterparts in those games, and when it comes to vision, hiding in shadows is much less effective for the player (splicers will have a harder time spotting you than when you're out in the open, but not to the degree that they do in, say, in Theif 2).
To go into a little more detail, splicers rely heavily on vision. They have near and far forward facing vision cones that have quite a narrow arc. If the player falls within these cones, it'll take the splicer some time to notice their presence. The amount of time is based on factors such as lighting, as mentioned, and the amount of the player's body that is obscured. The splicer will notice the player more quickly if the player is within their near vision cone, and longer if the player is standing within the far vision cone.
Splicers also have peripheral vision cones. They have peripheral vision in an almost 180 degree forward facing arc. If a splicer sees the player in their periphery, they will exclaim "Hey what's that!" and turn to face the player, putting the player squarely in their forward facing vision, giving them a chance to actually spot the player and then attack, unless the player reacts quickly enough to duck out of view before this happens. This was a tricky thing to balance; we wanted our AIs to be much more aware than in previous games, but still wanted situations to occur where it didn't feel like they were so absolutely aware of the player's presence at all times that there was no middle ground between "neutral" and "attacking" (for example, it didn't feel good to have a splicer immediately attack a player that it had spotted in its periphery).
Splicers also have backwards facing vision cones. If you sneak up behind a splicer, it won't hear you coming; it'll literally see you coming, because it has eyes in the back of it's head. This is spooky as hell and you will now have trouble sleeping tonight.
The tricky task I had in tuning splicer vision cones was in hitting some numbers that worked well in most situations across our game. All of Bioshock's levels are quite different from each other, and there is much environmental variation; large spaces, cramped spaces. Brightly lit caverns and dimly lit closets.
Finally, sound and hearing played a lesser role in splicer perception. Sounds could be tagged as "investigative" and given a radius. If a splicer hears one of these sounds, and it's source is in LOS, they will turn to face it, at which point they're relying on their vision cones to spot a possible target. If they hear one of these sounds and it's source is out of LOS, they will path to its location while always facing the source, and again, vision becomes key.
Sylvain: How did you handle spawning of enemies that wander around the world?
Dean: Bioshock levels are chopped up into regions, each of which has a desired population level that is split along the ecology lines; protectors (Big Daddies) and aggressors (Splicers). That desired population level is in most cases satisfied with scripted spawns or initial spawns when the player first enters the region; the player will enter the region, and it'll then be filled with AIs that spawn at designer-specified points and then do what they're told; either designers tell them to follow some scripted behavior, or the AI will do something systemic. Splicers will patrol (patrol points and paths are designer crafted), Big Daddies will seek out Little Sister vents, and then escort their Little Sister to dead bodies that hold Adam. We called these bodies "booty". Booty can be designer placed, or be dynamically spawned when a splicer dies.
When a region's population drops below the desired level, our population manager takes over. It'll wait a designer-specified amount of time before spawning in new enemies, and it'll spawn them at points which the level designer has specified. These points hold a bunch of variables that designers can change; enemy archetypes spawned, the chance for each type to spawn, and patrol path assignment. The system is actually quite simple, and very similar again to the spawning manager used in System Shock 2. Designers could tune spawning manager variables for each level, and for each region in a level; so there can be regions that have a high respawn rate, or a low respawn rate, differing population levels, etc. We used this to make some areas feel more dangerous or "busy" than others. Because every level designer could tailor-tune the system for their own specific level, we needed to develop some ground rules and best practices to ensure the system was somewhat consistent game-wide.
Sylvain: Did you have any strategies to avoid enemies killing each other when the player wasn't nearby or was this not an issue?
Dean: I'm a little iffy on the exact details of the LOD system we had in place (LOD stands for Level of Detail). I think it was something quite simple: AIs would deactivate their attack behaviors if they fell outside of a certain range of the player. The design also didn't really allow for random battles to break out amongst AIs unless the player was already close-by; in fact I don't think they can break out randomly. This could happen at some point reeeeeally early in development, and it basically created mayhem and chaos and an ecosystem that was impossible for players to understand. They would always end up coming across either battles in progress between Big Daddies and Splicers, or, much worse, rooms full of dead bodies. The former was bad because it made it very difficult to telegraph to players that Big Daddies only attack when provoked (which had been something quite unheard of in this genre), and the latter was worse because it made encounter pacing an impossible task for designers.
Sylvain: Finally, how did the AI evolve through the project and what lessons did you learn?
Dean: Our AIs evolved massively over the course of the project, though the basic archetypal foundation of each individual AI remained intact almost from day one; the grenadier (Nitro Splicer), assassin (Houdini Splicer), ranged aggressor (SMG Splicer, Pistol Splicer), melee aggressor (Melee Thug), the gatherer (Little Sister), the protectors (Big Daddies); we settled on the behavioral basics of each of these guys very early on, and then over the course of the project iterated on the details of their behaviors massively.
The Big Daddies are a good example of this. Early on, we intended to make these guys hulking, lumbering masses of muscle and power, and we stuck to this goal quite literally for a very long time. Their movements were very slowly, they had delayed reactions, were easily outran, their attacks were hugely damaging but had a long windup period, etc. As the game evolved from a slow-paced stat driven fps/RPG (that's rpg IN ALL CAPS!...fps in low caps...) into Shooter 2.0 I pushed to make our Big Daddies much more agile and reactive once they had become aggressive. I wanted there to be a clear difference between "neutral and mellow" and "angray!". I really enjoyed seeing player reactions to the huge behavioral switch that came when a Big Daddy decided that it needed to defend its Little Sister. "OH GOD, I THOUGHT THEY WERE SLOW!" players would scream, as a Bouncer smashed into their face with the speed of a freight-train, or a Rosie became impossible to outrun.
Another example of design aimed at "sticking to your base and iterating on the details" is the grenadier (AKA the Nitro Splicer); we knew early on that we wanted an AI that threw explosive projectiles. That was the basic design (and totally original, right guys?). As time went on, we layered more interesting behaviors and system interactions on top of this design base to make this AI more interesting; the grenadier gained the ability to throw Molotovs, to drop smoke grenades like chaff when retreating, and let loose a devastating kamikaze attack. Players could also catch their grenades by using the telekinesis plasmid.
Starting with a simple yet strong design base was I think in the end a very smart move (I'm not taking credit either; I very much worked on the details of each AI, but came into the project once they already had a strong base laid out). Though the basic design for each AI archetype wasn't exactly imaginative or completely original, we managed to create something fresh with each archetype by living in the details. This meant little wasted work. In fact, we shipped with almost every AI archetype that was originally conceived and designed, bar one Big Daddy archetype that made it very far into production before being cut; though you may see him re-appear sometime in the future, *wink*.
I'd like to point out one interesting thing that came out of the design process; these days, a lot of good AI design is focused on ensuring that AI states and behavioral intent is fed back to the player clearly, usually through the use of VO. Basically, AIs will scream out to the player what it is they intend to do. "I'm hiding!" or "Here comes a grenade!" or "Take cover!" or "Flank him!" or whatever. Our AI VO writer (and Audio Director) (and fellow Australian) (and my best mate!) Emily Ridgway pushed against this idea from very early on. She made the stylistic and creative choice to use our AI VO to help sell the idea that each splicer is a twisted, ruined husk of a person. A lost mind overtaken by dementia, paranoia and confusion. They're not battle-hardened soldiers employing military tactics against the player; they're lost and scared and want you to go away. And so, when writing lines for our splicers, she made the conscious decision not to have them clearly state their behavioral intentions. This was met with quite a bit of resistance, which I'm glad wasn't successful. I'm quite happy with the idea that in Bioshock, you never quite know what a splicer is thinking or planning...
I feel like I should end my response to this question with one big overarching "lesson-learned".
Let me think...
I know!
If you're going to end your game with a fight against a giant naked bronze man, you better really mean it.
Thursday, December 31, 2009
...wow what a year
One of the best years I think I've ever had. I'll have some new posts coming soon. Stuff to come:
- Pics from the last few months
- Q&A with Dean Tate (Senior Designer at Harmonix)
- Best of 2009 posts
- Pics from the last few months
- Q&A with Dean Tate (Senior Designer at Harmonix)
- Best of 2009 posts
Thursday, December 03, 2009
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)












